Choosing the Right Revolver for Beginners: Why Single Action is Not Always the Best
When it comes to firearms, and specifically revolvers, the choice between a single action (SA) and a double action/single action (DA/SA) revolver can be a crucial decision for beginners. While some enthusiasts believe that SA revolvers are always the best starting point, there are compelling reasons to consider a DA/SA revolver, which are not only easier to load and clear but also provide a more controlled shooting experience. This article aims to provide a comprehensive guide to help beginners choose the right tool for their journey into the world of firearms.
A Better Option for Beginners: DA/SA Revolvers
For new shooters, a double action/single action (DA/SA) revolver is often a better choice. This type of revolver offers the best of both worlds, combining the simplicity of a double action trigger with the precision of a single action hammer. DA/SA revolvers are easier to load and clear, and they can be fired in single action mode when the hammer is forward, providing more control for beginners. Additionally, many modern DA/SA revolvers come equipped with a transfer bar safety, a feature that significantly enhances safety. This safety mechanism, which is almost universal on DA/SA revolvers built in the last 30 years, prevents accidental discharges when the hammer is cocked. Since SA revolvers often do not have this safety feature, they can be more unpredictable and potentially overwhelming for new shooters. Understanding the function of an SA revolver can be challenging, especially for those new to firearms, and it can lead to dangerous mistakes.
Why Alec Baldwin's Incident is a Cautionary Tale
The case of acclaimed actor Alec Baldwin holding a single action revolver while filming, which led to a devastating accident, serves as a stark reminder of the potential risks associated with SA revolvers. Baldwin's misfired weapon, loaded with a live round, resulted in the accidental shooting of a prop mistress, leading to serious legal and personal repercussions. This incident highlights the temperamental nature of SA revolvers and the importance of selecting a firearm that minimizes the risk of such accidents. For new shooters, this kind of reliability and predictability is crucial.
Expert Insights: The Author's Experience as an Instructor
As an experienced firearms instructor and range safety officer, I have seen firsthand the challenges that new shooters face when using a single action revolver. When introducing new shooters to firearms, I often use a single action revolver to guide them and provide a structured learning experience. However, the process is slow and methodical, and beginners can sometimes become overwhelmed. To mitigate the risk of mistakes during excitement, I recommend that new shooters only fire one cartridge at a time, especially if they are using a SA revolver. This reduces the likelihood of involuntary second or third shots being fired.
My personal instruction method involves starting with a single action revolver and focusing on basic firearm handling, including muzzle discipline and trigger control. This gradual approach allows new shooters to build confidence and understanding before advancing to more complex firearms, such as semi-automatic pistols. Over the past 30 years, I have seen the effectiveness of this method, and it has been a staple of the initial firearm training for many new shooters.
Conclusion
While single action revolvers can certainly be easier and safer for some beginners, double action/single action (DA/SA) revolvers offer a more controlled and predictable shooting experience. They are easier to load and clear, provide better safety features, and can be fired in single action mode for more precise shooting. As an experienced firearms instructor, my preference is to start new shooters with a DA/SA revolver to help build their confidence and understanding of firearms. By doing so, we can help prevent accidents and ensure a positive, safe learning experience for beginners.
Ultimately, the key is to find a balance between simplicity and safety that meets the needs of the new shooter. Whether a beginner chooses a single action or a DA/SA revolver, the focus should always be on teaching proper handling and usage techniques to ensure a safe and enjoyable time in the shooting range.