Orthodox Jews' Admiration for Other Jewish Denominations: Values and Concerns

In the rich tapestry of the Jewish faith, various denominations exist, each with its unique characteristics and values. For Orthodox Jews, different aspects of other Jewish denominations evoke admiration and concern in equal measure. This article explores the reasons behind Orthodox Jews' admiration for secular and religious Jews, while also addressing their reservations towards liberal Judaism.

Admiration for Secular Jews in the Israeli Military

Orthodox Jews often draw inspiration from secular Jews who serve in the Israeli army. Their service and dedication to protecting Jewish people and the survival of Orthodox Judaism in Israel are deeply admired. As one Orthodox Jew puts it, 'Our Torah and our good deeds belong to them as much as they do to us.' Gratitude is often expressed for the contributions of these individuals, especially because their efforts have enabled the continuity of religious practices and beliefs.

Secular Israelis have also made significant contributions to the Israeli economy, fostering innovation and entrepreneurship. The term 'Start Up Nation' reflects the remarkable economic impact of secular Jews, who have built new industries and created jobs that benefit the entire Jewish community. The secular community's success in technology and innovation is seen as a source of pride and an example of Jewish ingenuity.

Encompassing Values and Cultural Preservation

The character traits of kindness, honesty, and education are highly valued across the board within the Jewish faith. Many Torah values are found in nonreligious Jews, often without them being aware of their origins. This shared heritage makes the transition back to observance seem more natural for many Jews. Orthodox and non-Orthodox Jews are essentially the same at their core, differing only in outward practices and observances.

Personal stories highlight this interconnection. For example, Michael Steinhardt, an atheist, has been credited with bringing thousands of Jews closer to their heritage in Israel. His efforts demonstrate that these values and traditions are ingrained in Jewish culture and can find their way into the hearts of individuals, even without intentional religious practice.

Reservations and Concerns towards Liberal Judaism

While there is much to admire in the contributions of secular Jews, Orthodox Jews have significant reservations about liberal forms of Judaism. The fear of assimilation and intermarriage is shared, which has led to a decline in the Jewish population. Many liberal Jewish movements are seen as having contributed to this decline, by deviating from traditional Orthodox practices and values.

These movements are viewed as destructive to the Jewish soul, often leading to a loss of religious identity. In some cases, the liberal agenda is perceived as promoting a form of Judaism that is increasingly meaningless and disconnected from the core spiritual principles. This shift is not only troubling but also deeply concerning for the future of the Jewish community.

Orthodox Jews argue that the continuation of traditional Jewish practices is essential for maintaining the identity and spiritual essence of the community. The idea that the answer to preserving Jewish identity is further liberalization is seen as a misguided approach. Instead, there is a call for a return to the roots of Jewish faith and a recognition of the importance of observance.

Ultimately, while there is commendation for the values and achievements of secular and religious Jews, the reservations about liberal Judaism stem from a deep-seated desire to ensure the survival and vitality of the Jewish community. The tragic reality highlighted by these concerns is a cautionary tale of the consequences of deviating from traditional pathways.