Professional Sports and the Utility of Mercy Rules: A Comparison Between MLB and 'The Show'
In the world of professional sports, the concept of a mercy rule is largely foreign. Unlike in video games or friendly games, where a mercy rule can bring an end to the agony quickly, the core principle in sports is that the fans paid to watch a game, and the players owe it to them to conclude the match meaningfully, even when one side is dominating the other.
Mercy Rules in Video Games and Friendly Games
Video games and friendly games often implement mercy rules to end games quickly, sparing players the prolonged burden of a losing streak. This is done because players in these contexts are not being paid to play, and their time could be better spent elsewhere. The emphasis lies on competition and personal improvement rather than despairing defeats.
MLB and 'The Show': Different Philosophies
Major League Baseball (MLB) operates under a different ethos. A team that dominates another is expected to take the losses and use them as learning opportunities. There’s no room for mercy in professional environments, as highlighted by scenarios like the infamous 22-1 defeat suffered by the Arizona Diamondbacks. Such moments in baseball are more about the journey of improvement.
MLB isn't beer league softball. In a professional setting, a win is a win, and a loss is a loss. Fans expect a meaningful game, and professional athletes are there to deliver. The idea of deliberately forfeiting by not fielding 9 players or intentionally striking out would be seen as a farce, undermining both the sport’s integrity and the value of the footwork that fans have purchased.
The Importance of Fair Play and Sportsmanship
Even in a game where one team is completely outplaying the other, professional players are expected to give it their all until the very last out. In baseball, there’s always the chance for comebacks, and no lead is ever safe until the last batter is out. This dynamic is what makes the sport so thrilling and unpredictable, from the 9th inning onwards.
The real reason there is no mercy rule in professional sports is rooted in professional pride and the belief that any player, no matter how bad a game, should leave the field with the knowledge that they gave it their best shot.
The Drawbacks of Mercy Rules
Implementing a mercy rule can have its drawbacks, particularly in terms of record-keeping. High-scoring games can lead to remarkable individual performances, such as a player hitting 15 home runs or achieving an incredible batting average. These moments are what fans often cherish.
The Professional Aspect of Sports
Professional sports are about going out and performing your best every day. Even in tough times, players are expected to do their best to win the game. This is why forfeiting a game to end the suffering would be seen as a disgrace. It penalizes the dominant team and undermines the competitive spirit that drives the sport.
Ultimately, the pendulum will swing, and it will be the less-talented team’s turn to suffer another beating, ensuring the integrity and excitement of the game are preserved.
Links References:
Official MLB Website
Image Source: Unsplash