The Best 50 ft Catamaran for Cruising: A Comprehensive Review

Choosing the right 50 ft catamaran can be a daunting task, especially with such a diverse range of options available. Matt Pickering's answer provides a solid starting point, but it's important to explore other perspectives to make an informed decision.

Introduction

When it comes to catamarans, the choice is often between affordability, performance, and comfort. One user's experience with Lagoon catamarans shed some light on their heavy and sluggish nature, highlighting the trade-offs involved. While the Fontaine Pajots were initially favored, changes in the market make it less relevant for current discussions.

Another critical factor is the reliability and maintenance of the catamarans, particularly when they are purchased from different regions. One friend's experience with a South African catamaran, which included significant challenges, underscores the importance of thorough research and warranty options before making a purchase.

The St. Francis 50: A Top Choice for Cruisers

Our choice for the best 50 ft catamaran to cruise falls on the St. Francis 50. Our friend, who owns one, praises the boat for its speed and ease of handling, even when sailing solo. The St. Francis line has been continually improving, with the late Mk.1 model being significantly lighter than earlier versions, and the Mk.2 models set to release this year.

The St. Francis 50 offers a blend of performance and comfort, making it a standout in its class. This boat can achieve a comfortable cruising speed of 7 knots with one engine and can sail up to 30 degrees off the wind while still managing 10 knots. Even in light winds, the boat can maintain a respectable speed of 5-6 knots. Downwind, equipped with a spinnaker, the St. Francis has a top performance of 17.5 knots in 30 knots of wind, though it might be a bit overpowered under such conditions.

Pros and Cons of the St. Francis 50

Pros:

Speed and Performance: The boat is well-regarded for its ability to sail efficiently and maintain high speeds in various wind conditions. Handiness: It is noted for its ease of handling, particularly for single-handed operations. Comfort and Accommodation: While the cabins are modern and well-designed, the interior layout is more minimalist in terms of guest accommodations, which might be more comfortable for solo sailors or cruisers seeking a simpler lifestyle. Continual Improvements: The St. Francis line has seen constant improvements, making the Mk.1 and Mk.2 models stand out in terms of performance and design.

Cons:

Minimalist Accommodation: The guest cabins are described as spartan, designed more for comfort and performance than luxury. Design Norm: The narrow hull design and internal layout of the St. Francis 50 could be a drawback for those prioritizing spaciousness and comfort.

Conclusion

In summary, the St. Francis 50 stands out as an excellent choice for those seeking a high-performance cruising catamaran. While it may not be the pinnacle of all features, it excels in key areas such as speed, handling, and design improvements. The decision to purchase a 50 ft catamaran should involve careful consideration of individual needs and lifestyle preferences. Whether you prioritize performance, comfort, or both, the St. Francis 50 offers a compelling option for the discerning sailor.

Further Reading

For more detailed comparisons and reviews, you can explore the following resources:

Cruisers Forum Sailing Magazine Reviews Catamaran News Reviews