Why Aren't Garbage Bags Biodegradable?

When it comes to waste management, the ultimate goal is to minimize the environmental impact of our daily activities. However, traditional plastic garbage bags contribute significantly to the problem by filling landfills and harming the environment. The search for a sustainable alternative has led to the development of biodegradable garbage bags, but these too come with their own limitations. In this article, we will explore why biodegradable garbage bags are not as widely available as one might hope and discuss the current options and future possibilities.

Introduction to Biodegradable Bag Alternatives

Shopping for trash bags today, you might notice a variety of options labeled as 'biodegradable.' However, these bags often do not live up to the expectation of being a green solution. The Better Home Compostable Garbage Bags, for instance, are made from Poly Lactic Acid (PLA) derived from corn starch. While these bags are compostable in commercial facilities, they do not break down entirely in landfills, which is a critical factor in waste management.

Shop Now: Better Home Compostable Garbage Bags (link)

Biodegradable versus Compostable Trash Bags

While there are biodegradable and compostable garbage bags on the market, they are not always the most practical choice. Biodegradable trash bags are often marketed as a eco-friendly alternative, but their performance can vary widely.

For example, biodegradable trash bags are typically very thin and may tear easily. This can be problematic when you have a lot of wet or heavy garbage that needs to be managed. Unless you have access to a proper composting facility, these bags may not degrade as quickly or effectively as advertised, leading to frustration and waste.

Previous Attempts at Biodegradable Garbage Bags

Interestingly, some companies have tried to develop biodegradable garbage bags in the past. These bags were often made from a cornstarch-based polymer, designed to mimic the look and feel of traditional plastic bags. They were even waterproof to some extent, meaning they could be used in regular households.

However, a major problem arose when the bags were exposed to wet garbage. The cornstarch-based material melted or deteriorated when in contact with moisture for an extended period. This led to the bottom of the bags falling apart when removed from the trash can, which was a significant inconvenience for users. These products were ultimately discontinued due to their unreliability and performance issues.

Challenges in Producing Biodegradable Bags

The production of biodegradable garbage bags is not without its challenges. While there are several biodegradable plastics available, they require specific conditions to decompose. These conditions include high temperatures (80°C) and a duration of 72 hours, which is beyond the capabilities of most commercial composting facilities. Additionally, these processes are often energy-intensive and cost-prohibitive.

Moreover, the definition of biodegradability can vary. Some bags may break down in certain environments, but they might still release harmful substances or take a long time to decompose fully. This can be problematic, as it may not truly solve the issue of waste accumulation in landfills.

Alternatives to Biodegradable Bags

Given the limitations of current biodegradable bags, alternative solutions are being explored. One such option is the separation and recycling of waste into streams that can be reused. This approach focuses on maximizing the reusability of materials and converting non-reusable waste into energy through controlled burning or other processes.

Landfills are often seen as the least desirable solution for waste management, as they take up valuable space and release harmful gases. The best approach is to separate waste into streams that can be reused as much as possible. Recovering the energy locked up in waste is another viable option, as it offers a way to process non-reusable materials in an environmentally friendly manner.

Key Takeaways:

Biodegradable garbage bags are not a perfect solution and often do not break down completely in landfills. Current biodegradable bags can be thin and fragile, especially when dealing with wet garbage. Previous attempts at biodegradable garbage bags like cornstarch-based materials have faced performance issues and were ultimately discontinued. Alternative waste management methods, such as separation and recycling, offer more sustainable and effective solutions than biodegradable bags alone.

While biodegradable garbage bags represent a step towards sustainability, they are not the ultimate solution to our waste management challenges. By exploring and implementing alternative methods, we can work towards a more sustainable future.