Why Conservative Catholics Disregard Pope Francis' Focus on the Poor and Oppressed

In the ideological realm, true religion emerges as the only escape. For clarity, the ideological realm refers to the realm dominated by progressive and traditionalist ideologies. In Catholic life, particularly in the United States, these two major manifestations are akin to the two sides of Caesar's coin.

The Role of Progressivism

Progressivism operates by envisioning a future utopian state and striving to achieve it through political means. The sin lies in the belief that by ordering our lives according to our desires, which represent man's fallen nature (the Original Sin), we can create something good. This is a misguided and harmful approach, as attempting to create a perfect world through political actions often leads to unintended negative consequences.

The Role of Traditionalism

Traditionalism, on the other hand, looks to the past to find solutions and inspiration. While this approach also represents a sin, manifested in a different orientation, it still perpetuates a problematic cycle by refusing to acknowledge the current realities and focusing on an idealized past. Both progressivism and traditionalism are forms of escapism from the present, using either the future or the past as a refuge from the complexities of the current moment.

Church Tradition and Ideological Equivalents

The term traditionalist is often used in a misleading way. It is often equated with the historical and cultural practices of the Church, which can lead to misunderstandings. The Church's tradition is a living, ever-present reality that is only relevant in the historical moment, here and now. The traditionalist, as the term is often used, is more of an approach to life than a reflection of the authenticity of Church teachings.

Conservative Catholics and Their Disregard

Conservative Catholics, who often adhere more strictly to traditional practices, may feel justified in ignoring Pope Francis' focus on the poor and oppressed. This disregard can be rooted in their belief that the traditional practices and ways of thinking are more aligned with the teachings of the Church. However, this perspective may be an ideological projection, allowing them to maintain a comfortable distance from what they perceive as a deviation from traditional teachings.

The Promise of Communion and Personal Responsibility

Pope Francis emphasizes the importance of personal responsibility and the need to follow Jesus. By receiving communion, Catholics make an implicit promise that they are willing and ready to take on their own cross and follow Jesus. This promise obligates them to actively engage with the Church's teachings and directives, including those of the Pope. Disregarding the Pope's focus on the poor and oppressed, therefore, goes against the promise made during communion, highlighting a gap between words and actions.

The Papacy and the Office of the Pope

Pope Francis has made it clear that in his informal statements, such personal opinions do not represent the authority of the Papacy. He has thus rendered the office of the Papacy largely irrelevant, as he seldom uses his position to speak authoritatively. This approach may alienate some Catholics who expect clear and direct guidance from the head of the Church.

In conclusion, the disregard by conservative Catholics of Pope Francis' focus on the poor and oppressed is a complex issue rooted in both ideological beliefs and personal interpretations. Understanding the Church's tradition and the responsibility that comes with receiving communion are crucial steps toward addressing this challenge.