Why So Many Choose Asphalt Roofs Over Lifespan Options

When deciding the type of roof you want to install on your property, you have options that range from cost-effective asphalt shingles to more expensive, long-lasting options like metal roofs. While many property owners opt for asphalt roofs in the 15-20 year range, some are considering the alternative of a long-lasting roof solution, often referred to as a 'lifeline roof.' Let's explore why so many people choose asphalt roofs over these long-lasting alternatives.

The Cost Factor

One of the primary reasons people choose asphalt roofs is the cost. Asphalt shingles can be quite affordable, making them an attractive option for homeowners on a budget. In a market where expenses are a major concern, the lower upfront cost of asphalt can be a significant factor in the decision-making process. For many, this lower cost provides financial relief, allowing them to allocate their resources to other important home improvements or maintenance needs.

Aesthetic Appeal

Another popular reason for choosing asphalt roofs is their aesthetic appeal. Many homeowners prefer the look of the classic asphalt shingle. These roofs come in a variety of colors and styles, making them versatile and easy to match with the architectural style of the home. As a result, some homeowners find that asphalt roofs enhance the curb appeal of their property, making it more attractive and potentially increasing its resale value.

Building Regulations and Codes

Local building regulations and codes also play a role in roof choice. In many areas, specific roofing materials and designs are mandated by local building codes. Asphalt roofs are often the preferred material for residential use due to their durability and cost-effectiveness. Even if lifelong roofs are available, they may not meet the requirements set by local authorities, making asphalt a more practical and compliant choice.

Do Long-Lived Roofs Exist?

While the concept of a "lifeline roof"—one that can last the entire lifetime of the building—is appealing, it's important to understand that no roof is completely immune to the effects of the elements and wear and tear. Long-lasting roofs, made of materials such as metal, can certainly offer significant improvements in durability, potentially extending the roof's lifespan to 50 years or more. However, all roofs ultimately require some form of maintenance, and some may need to be replaced over time. For example, the roof on my current house is guaranteed for 50 years, but it may still require occasional repairs or maintenance to keep it in good condition.

Additional Considerations: Metal Roofs

For those considering more long-lasting options, metal roofs are a popular choice. However, while they do offer significant advantages, they also come with their own set of challenges. One common misconception is that you can safely drink water from a metal roof. In reality, the water collected from a metal roof is not recommended for consumption due to potential contaminants and build-up. Rainwater can pick up pollutants from the environment, making it unsuitable for drinking.

Another consideration is the noise factor. While metal roofs can be more aesthetically pleasing, they can also be noisier, especially during heavy rain or hail. This can be a significant factor for those living in areas with frequent storms. The sound can be disruptive and may affect the overall quietness of the environment.

Conclusion

The choice between an asphalt roof and a more expensive, long-lasting option often comes down to cost, appearance, and practicality. While asphalt shingles are more affordable and aesthetically pleasing, they may need to be replaced within 15-20 years. Metal roofs, while offering longer durability and improved sustainability, come with their own set of challenges, including potential contamination of collected rainwater and increased noise levels during storms.

Additional Information

For those concerned about the purity of the water collected from a metal roof, remember that rainwater, even in non-industrialized areas, can pick up contaminants as it falls through the air. Drinking such water directly is not recommended, as it can contain pollutants. Instead, consider the most efficient use of this water for purposes like watering the lawn or garden, where treated water is typically more expensive. This way, you can make the most of the collected rainwater while ensuring your health and the environment.