Why Some Covers Outshine the Originals: A Case Study
Songs have been covering each other for decades, from classic rock to modern pop. While many cover versions aim to replicate the original, some manage to shine in a way that transcends mere imitation. This article explores several instances where a cover version has been deemed superior to its original, analyzing the elements that make these covers stand out.
Eric Cartman’s “Come Sail Away”
Eric Cartman, a character known for his darker and more irreverent take on things in the South Park series, brings a unique perspective to the song “Come Sail Away” by covering it in a memorable way. The song, originally by Seline Dawn, has become a touchstone for more serious versions. However, Eric Cartman’s rendition takes it to a different level, capturing the shallowness and idiocy of the original with an unflinching critique.
Aretha Franklin’s “Spanish Harlem”
Aretha Franklin’s version of “Spanish Harlem” by Ben E. King is a prime example of how a cover can elevate a song. Franklin’s great groove and powerful voice restore the song to a level of depth that the original lacked. Her rendition is not just a cover; it’s a rebirth of the song with a fresh, compelling essence.
Dave Edmunds’ “Feelin Alright”
One of Dave Edmunds’ most celebrated remakes is “Feelin Alright,” originally by The Breakfast Club. While Edmunds’ version is a worthy standalone song, it also proves that even classic hits benefit from a reworking. His interpretation captures the essence of the original in a way that resonates more deeply, thereby enhancing the listener’s experience.
The Bangles’ “Hazy Shade of Winter”
The version of “Hazy Shade of Winter” by the Bangles 15 years after its original release stands as a testament to how a song can evolve. Although Simon Garfunkel’s original was a good track, the Bangles’ rendition added a new layer of maturity and energy that made it a Great song in its own right. This revival captured a different audience and provided a fresh perspective on the classic.
Smokey Robinson’s “Tears of a Clown”
The English Beat’s ska cover of Smokey Robinson’s “Tears of a Clown” is a prime example of a cover that not only reimagines the original but also adds a unique flavor. This version not only stays true to the soulful spirit of the original but also introduces a ska infused rhythm, creating a song that feels both familiar and entirely new. It’s a testament to the enduring power of the original while also showing how it can be rejuvenated for a new generation.
Jimmy Hendrix’s “All Along the Watchtower”
Besides Bob Dylan’s own version of “All Along the Watchtower,” Jimmy Hendrix’s guitar-driven rendition is perhaps the most famous and influential interpretation. Dylan himself has acknowledged the power of Hendrix’s version, highlighting how it can bring a new life to an iconic song. This cover changed the landscape of the song and has become a quintessential part of rock lore.
Joy Oladokun’s Covers
One of the most compelling modern examples is Joy Oladokun’s cover of Nirvana’s “Smells Like Teen Spirit.” Her rendition, titled “I See America/Smells Like Teen Spirit,” infuses the song with a new perspective and a deeply emotive quality. Her lyrics shift the focus from the original’s rebellious spirit to a more personal and reflective tone, evoking a strong emotional response in listeners.
Conclusion
While covers often aim to replicate the original, there are instances where they surpass the original. Whether through improvements in sound quality, fresh interpretations, or new perspectives, these covers offer a fresh take on beloved songs. This phenomenon highlights the enduring power of music to evolve and touch audiences in different ways, proving that a cover can indeed be better than the original.